From Garage Sale to Marketplace Growth

Not Everyone Starts with a Strategy

Sometimes ecommerce careers begin with a box of Yu-Gi-Oh cards and a shipping mistake. (True story—shoutout to Noah Wickham.)

But what separates hobbyists from pros? It’s not how you start. It’s how fast you learn, adapt, and scale.

Key Lessons from the Early Days

That first botched transaction? It’s ecommerce 101 in disguise. Here’s what it taught:

  • Packaging matters. Ship a collector card in a plain envelope? Prepare for bent corners, chargebacks, and angry DMs.

  • Buyers care about presentation. Even if they only spent four bucks.

  • Every mistake is tuition. And tuition only becomes debt if you don’t apply the lesson.

That messy start? It’s not unique. Every seller has one. The difference is who keeps making rookie mistakes—and who graduates to brand builder.

What That Has to Do With Brands Today

Those small-scale issues are just foreshadows of the chaos that happens at scale:

  • Listing errors → Confused shoppers, bad CX, and returns

  • Poor packaging → Damaged goods and 1-star reviews

  • No SOPs → Internal chaos and team burnout

Want to act like a brand? Start thinking like a system.

Because the truth is: the marketplace doesn’t care if you started scrappy. It only cares if you can deliver at scale.

You don’t have to launch perfectly. But you do have to scale professionally.

For the full conversation, watch Season 3, Episode 18 of The Longer Game with Noah Wickham.



Michael Maher

Musician turned business owner, I now own and run a Custom Done-For-You Amazon Services Agency and love it. From content to catalog management, advertising to international expansion, my agency Cartology is taking your brand story and translating it into a catalog that grows awareness, generates revenue, and achieves profitability on the Amazon marketplace.

I love my wife and daughter, being a human, bourbon, coffee, and being a light in business world.

https://thinkcartology.com
Next
Next

Amazon Isn’t Broken—It’s Just Growing Up