Auctions Aren’t Dead. Your Strategy Is.

Auctions aren’t Just for Grandma’s China Anymore

Most brands treat auctions like a dusty attic, full of nostalgia and not much else. But that’s a mistake. Because they have quietly leveled up, and it’s no longer just Sotheby’s and eBay running the show.

Today, auctions are showing up in modern DTC brands, creator storefronts, and even pop culture drops. You just haven’t noticed, because the smartest players aren’t bragging. They’re banking.

Why Auctions Deserve a Second Look

Auctions aren’t about selling old stuff. They’re about:

  • Pricing based on demand, not assumptions

  • Building urgency without fake scarcity

  • Creating press-worthy moments for product drops

  • Capturing deep buyer intent (and valuable data)

Translation? You’re leaving money—and data—on the table if "Buy Now" is your only pricing strategy.

Pharrell Didn’t List on eBay for a Reason

When Pharrell Williams wanted to launch his Jupiter auction site, he didn’t go to eBay. He used Basta. Why? Because he wanted control, customer data, and brand equity.

He had:

  • Rare memorabilia

  • A loyal fanbase

  • A story to tell

Auctions gave him a way to turn all three into serious revenue, on his terms.

This Isn’t a Gimmick. It’s a Tactic.

The old-school narrative: Auctions are niche. 

The 2025 narrative: Auctions are underutilized.

You want to:

  • Move high-value or one-off SKUs? Auction it.

  • Test what people are really willing to pay? Auction it.

  • Drive traffic and create a campaign moment? Yep—auction it.

This is especially potent for:

  • Limited drops

  • Collabs

  • Upcycled fashion or rare SKUs

Auctions aren’t outdated, they’re underused. Stop guessing your price. Let your customers fight for it.

If you want the full breakdown, it’s in Season 3, Episode 19 of The Longer Game with Jake Goodman.



Michael Maher

Musician turned business owner, I now own and run a Custom Done-For-You Amazon Services Agency and love it. From content to catalog management, advertising to international expansion, my agency Cartology is taking your brand story and translating it into a catalog that grows awareness, generates revenue, and achieves profitability on the Amazon marketplace.

I love my wife and daughter, being a human, bourbon, coffee, and being a light in business world.

https://thinkcartology.com
Next
Next

From Garage Sale to Marketplace Growth